When Not to Automate Your Marketing Operations

With the not-so-recent ‘new wave’ of artificial intelligence, it’s become extremely tempting for teams to automate marketing operations across the board. Whilst there are very valid use cases for automating with the help of AI, it is not always the best practice. In this blog, we’ll look at key reasons not to automate certain parts of your marketing operations, and offer tips to avoid common pitfalls when you do.

3D image of eBook with header A Guide to Agentforce and Einstein for Marketers
Free ResourceDownload now

Marketing automation is one of the most powerful tools at your disposal when it’s used intentionally. For many marketing leaders, automation promises efficiency, scale, and measurable ROI

Yet the truth is, over-automation can have the opposite effect: eroding trust with customers, skewing performance data, and making your brand feel impersonal. Knowing what not to automate is just as critical as knowing what to automate, especially when your C-suite is watching metrics closely.

Don’t automate: The first sales call

As a general rule, good marketing automation will enhance trust and bad automation will depreciate trust. It all comes down to how authentic a customer interaction feels.

For example, when arranging a first sales call, we want to ensure that this is done on a one-to-one basis; a real conversation with a real salesperson. First interactions with someone interested in your product/services are important for building trust, and the human element in this instance should not be underestimated. It’s vital that your would-be customers feel heard in your first interaction, or else you risk losing them.

From a marketing ROI perspective, that first touchpoint is one of the most influential in determining conversion rate. Automating this stage, even something as simple as an impersonal calendar link sent from a bot, can make prospects feel like they’ve entered a system rather than a partnership. 

Marketing leaders should think of this as an investment moment: every genuine, human-led call that converts strengthens your case for future automation budgets, because you’re showing that automation enhances, not replaces, the human connection.

Don’t automate: When data is low-quality

If you can’t be confident in the quality of your data, you should avoid automation. 

For example, you have doubts over how accurate job title data is, but you want to send an email campaign to C-suite decision-makers. If you were to automate email marketing in this instance, you risk pulling the wrong contacts into your campaign and alienating them, wasting everybody’s time. 

Poor data quality is one of the most common reasons automation efforts fail to deliver ROI. For marketing managers trying to prove value to senior stakeholders, inaccurate data damages campaign reporting and reduces confidence in your numbers. 

Before scaling automation, invest in a data audit and segmentation strategy. This ensures every automated journey, nurture, and campaign that follows is rooted in clean, reliable information that supports meaningful insight and performance tracking.

Don’t automate: During client or employee onboarding

In many cases, when onboarding a client or even a new employee, we should avoid defaulting to automation. 

Why? When a new client has gone through an extensive, value-building process with your sales team, the last thing they want is to receive a fully automated onboarding series that completely misses the personal touch. 

Of course, automated onboarding might be essential in some cases, so this one isn’t a hard and fast rule, but even if your process is automated, it’s worth supplementing these comms with outreach from your sales rep so as not to lose the personal touch.

Using a human or hybrid approach can increase trust, and customers will feel valued at a critical stage: when they’re new to your company. 

For senior marketers, this balance also safeguards long-term retention metrics, which are a critical element of demonstrating marketing ROI. The onboarding experience shapes customer lifetime value (CLV) and renewal likelihood. Even a small gesture of personalisation from your sales or success team can reduce churn and boost satisfaction scores. Hybrid automation, when done right, helps marketing directors prove that automation and empathy can coexist to drive measurable revenue growth.

Don’t automate: When generating content

With AI like Salesforce Agentforce and HubSpot Breeze at everyone’s fingertips these days, it can be really easy to ask AI to write an email for your marketing campaign. There’s nothing wrong with this, and it can help speed up content generation and campaign launches. However, if we completely automate content without human oversight or interaction, we lose brand identity and an authentic voice. 

Staying true to your prospects and clients’ interests and what brought them to your company, services, or products in the first place means keeping a firm hold on content creation and vetting every piece to ensure it meets your guidelines and doesn’t read like AI. 

From an operational perspective, AI-generated content can help you scale faster, but content that performs well with both humans and search engines still requires strategy, tone, and relevance. The most successful marketing teams use automation tools to support creativity, not replace it. 

Before publishing, ensure that human editors review each piece for accuracy and alignment with your brand’s messaging pillars. This will keep your campaigns engaging and protect your long-term reputation, which is ultimately what drives ROI.

Automation should enable marketers to work smarter, without stripping away the creativity, connection, and credibility that make your brand unique. As marketing leaders, it’s your responsibility to define where technology ends and human value begins. When you strike the right balance, you’ll not only gain the trust of your audience but also the confidence of your executive team.

Don’t lose the human touch in a world full of automation. Get in touch to discuss how MarCloud can help you stay authentic while scaling marketing operations.

Sam Green

Sam Green

Sam has a background in managing projects and tours for some of the world's biggest orchestras and performing arts groups. Having learned about marketing automation and Salesforce in his free time, he embarked on a career change which led him to MarCloud. This started with a Project Management role before moving into Sales where he now enjoys creating collaborative working relationships between our clients and experts at MarCloud. He holds the Account Engagement (Pardot) Consultant Certification and loves seeing our client's success stories having worked with MarCloud to solve their problems.

More by Sam Green

Featured resource

3D image of eBook with header A Guide to Agentforce and Einstein for Marketers

A Guide to Agentforce & Einstein for Marketers

By the end of the free guide, you’ll know what each tool does, how it fits into your existing processes, and why adopting Agentforce now is key to staying ahead. If you’re ready to see how AI can save you time and deliver a stronger ROI, you need this eBook.

Download now
View all resources

More recent posts

Coloured background with How to Master the HubSpot Salesforce Sync headline

How to Master the HubSpot Salesforce Sync

A lot of marketing teams are using HubSpot Marketing Hub, whilst their sales teams are operating out of Salesforce Sales Cloud. This is a perfectly reliable setup as long as the HubSpot Salesforce integration between the two is maintained. One of the challenges we often hear is related to Lead Assignment and how/when HubSpot can create records in Sales Cloud. Lead Assignment via the HubSpot-Salesforce integration is what we will cover in this blog.

View all articles
Illustrated characters holding a MarCloud banner

Get expert Salesforce & HubSpot automation tips, straight to your inbox.

MarCloud is a team of certified Pardot, Marketing Cloud, and Salesforce specialists. We help businesses to unlock the potential of marketing automation. Join 2,000+ professionals who receive actionable insights to boost their automation performance.

Sign up to the newsletter

A Guide to Agentforce & Einstein for Marketers

Learn what each tool does, how it fits into your existing processes, and why adopting Agentforce now is key to staying ahead.

Download now